How to Write Headlines That Convert

Your headline is your first and often only chance to capture attention. Studies show 80% of visitors read the headline but only 20% continue to the body content.

A great headline can double or triple your conversion rate. A weak headline guarantees failure regardless of what follows.

Why Headlines Matter So Much

The 5-Second Test

Visitors decide in seconds whether to stay or leave. The headline is the primary factor in that decision:

• Does this match what I expected?
• Is this relevant to me?
• Is this worth my time?

Ad Message Match

For paid traffic, headlines must match the ad:

• Ad: “Get More Leads for Your Agency”
• Landing page headline: “Get More Leads for Your Agency”

Mismatch creates confusion and bounces.

Search Intent Match

For organic traffic, headlines should deliver what searchers wanted:

• Search: “how to improve conversion rate”
• Headline: “How to Improve Your Conversion Rate: 15 Proven Methods”

Headline Formulas That Work

The “How To” Formula

Structure: How to [Achieve Desired Outcome]

Examples:

• “How to Double Your Email List in 30 Days”
• “How to Write Proposals That Win More Business”
• “How to Stop Losing Customers to Competitors”

Why it works: Promises practical, actionable value.

The Benefit + Specificity Formula

Structure: [Specific Benefit] + [Timeframe/Quantity]

Examples:

• “Generate 50% More Leads This Quarter”
• “Cut Your Ad Costs by 40% in 2 Weeks”
• “Build Your First App in One Weekend”

Why it works: Specificity makes the promise believable.

The Negative + Solution Formula

Structure: [Stop/End/Avoid] [Pain Point]

Examples:

• “Stop Wasting Money on Ads That Don’t Convert”
• “End the Frustration of Inconsistent Sales”
• “Avoid the 5 Mistakes Killing Your Conversions”

Why it works: People are motivated to avoid pain.

The Number List Formula

Structure: [Number] [Ways/Tips/Secrets] to [Outcome]

Examples:

• “7 Secrets to Landing Pages That Convert at 10%+”
• “21 Email Subject Lines That Get Opened”
• “5 Changes That Doubled Our Revenue”

Why it works: Numbers promise clear, finite content. Odd numbers often perform better.

The Question Formula

Structure: [Question that resonates with reader’s problem]

Examples:

• “Is Your Website Losing Sales While You Sleep?”
• “What Would You Do With 3X More Leads?”
• “Tired of Watching Competitors Win Your Customers?”

Why it works: Questions engage readers and imply solution follows.

The Proof/Results Formula

Structure: How [We/Client] [Achieved Result]

Examples:

• “How We Increased Conversion Rate 340% in 6 Months”
• “How One SaaS Company Added $2M ARR Through Better Onboarding”
• “The Strategy That Generated 1,000 Leads in 30 Days”

Why it works: Real results are compelling and credible.

The Ultimate Guide Formula

Structure: The [Ultimate/Complete/Definitive] Guide to [Topic]

Examples:

• “The Complete Guide to E-commerce Conversion Optimization”
• “The Ultimate Landing Page Blueprint”
• “The Definitive Guide to A/B Testing”

Why it works: Promises comprehensive value, suggests authority.

Headline Principles

Clarity Over Cleverness

Clever but unclear: “Think Outside the Inbox”

Clear and effective: “Email Marketing Strategies That Generate 40% More Revenue”

Puns and wordplay often confuse rather than convert.

Benefit, Not Feature

Feature-focused: “AI-Powered Analytics Dashboard”

Benefit-focused: “See Which Campaigns Are Making Money (And Which Are Wasting It)”

Readers care about outcomes, not capabilities.

Speak to One Person

Too broad: “Businesses Can Grow Revenue With Our Platform”

Specific audience: “Agency Owners: Double Your Retainer Revenue”

The more specific your audience targeting, the more relevant the message.

Create Urgency When Appropriate

Generic: “Improve Your Marketing”

With urgency: “Fix These 5 Landing Page Mistakes Before Your Next Campaign”

Urgency motivates action, but don’t force it where it doesn’t fit.

Match Awareness Level

Problem-unaware audience: Lead with the problem “Is Slow Loading Speed Killing Your Sales?”

Solution-aware audience: Lead with the solution “The Fast-Loading Website Builder for E-commerce”

Product-aware audience: Lead with differentiation “Faster Than Shopify. Easier Than WordPress.”

Writing Process

Step 1: Know Your Audience

Before writing, clarify:

• Who is this for?
• What do they want?
• What do they fear?
• What have they tried?
• What would make them act?

Step 2: Identify the Core Benefit

What’s the single most compelling thing you offer?

• Time saved?
• Money made?
• Problem solved?
• Risk avoided?

Lead with this.

Step 3: Write 20 Headlines

Don’t stop at your first idea:

• Write quickly, don’t self-edit
• Try different formulas
• Vary length and approach
• Include some wild ideas

Step 4: Evaluate and Refine

Score headlines against:

• Is it clear?
• Is it specific?
• Does it promise value?
• Does it match audience awareness?
• Would I click this?

Step 5: Test Winners

Never assume you know best:

• A/B test top headline candidates
• Let data decide the winner
• Keep testing over time

Common Headline Mistakes

Too Vague

❌ “Better Marketing for Your Business” ✅ “Generate 50% More Leads With Better Landing Pages”

Too Long

❌ “The Complete and Comprehensive Guide to Understanding, Implementing, and Optimizing Conversion Rate Optimization for Your E-commerce Business” ✅ “The E-commerce CRO Guide: From 2% to 5% Conversion”

No Benefit

❌ “Welcome to Our Platform” ✅ “Triple Your Email Response Rates Starting Today”

Feature-Focused

❌ “Machine Learning-Powered Optimization Engine” ✅ “Set It and Forget It: Automatic Campaign Optimization”

Clickbait Without Substance

❌ “This One Weird Trick Will Shock You!” ✅ “The Counterintuitive Strategy That Increased Our Conversions 127%“

Ignoring the Subheadline

The subheadline is part of your headline system:

• Expands on the promise
• Adds credibility or specificity
• Addresses secondary concerns

Example pairing: Headline: “Double Your Conversion Rate” Subheadline: “The proven 5-step framework used by 500+ SaaS companies to turn more visitors into customers”

Testing Headlines

What to Test

• Different formulas (How-to vs. Number list)
• Different benefits (save time vs. make money)
• Different specificity levels
• With/without numbers
• Question vs. statement
• Urgency vs. no urgency

How to Test

A/B testing:

• Minimum 2 weeks or until significant
• Primary metric: conversion rate
• Secondary: bounce rate, time on page

Ad testing:

• Test headlines as ad copy first
• Cheaper and faster data collection
• Winning ad headlines often win on landing pages

What to Measure

• Conversion rate (primary)
• Bounce rate
• Scroll depth
• Time on page
• Click-through rate (if applicable)

Headlines for Different Contexts

Landing Pages

• Match traffic source expectations
• Focus on single offer/benefit
• Clear and direct

Email Subject Lines

• Create curiosity or urgency
• Often shorter (40-50 characters)
• Personalization can help

Blog Posts

• SEO keyword inclusion
• Promise valuable content
• Can be longer than landing pages

Ads

• Stop the scroll
• Qualify audience quickly
• Must match landing page

Headline Swipe File Starters

Keep a collection of headlines that caught your attention. Study what works:

Outcome + Timeframe: “[Outcome] in [Timeframe]”

The Secret: “The Secret to [Desired Outcome]”

Without Pain: “[Desired Outcome] Without [Common Pain]”

Even If: “[Desired Outcome] Even If [Objection]”

Finally: “Finally, [Solution to Long-Standing Problem]”

Warning: “Warning: [Thing They’re Doing] Is [Negative Consequence]“

Ready to Improve Your Conversions?

Get a comprehensive CRO audit with actionable insights you can implement right away.

Request Your Audit — $2,500